Be sure to review us on Facebook and Yelp!

Here's what our customers have to say:

+ The best deli sandwiches downtown, and worth a trip in if you aren't close by. Also have excellent daily soup specials and amazing baked goods. So glad they are right next door! - Amy

+ Ate at Bagelicious for the first time this morning and i really enjoyed it. The staff was very kind and professional, and the food was great as well. If you live anywhere around the Appleton area and are looking for a great spot to have a quick bite before work or even brunch you should eat there. They have a great selection of food as well not just Bagels but they have sandwiches and Soups as well. I will definitely be coming back to Bagelicious in the future! - Cody

+ Stopped in over my lunch today to grab a sandwich. Such a nice place! Friendly people and a sandwich way better than the sub chains can provide! Highly recommend you stop and try. - Sarah

+ Bagelicious bagels are amazing!!! We just served 1,000 to our employees and had the best feedback!!! Super service and Kyle is great to work with. You should check them out!!! - TNF Recruiting

+ Kyle and his crew are just as amazing as the food is. My favorite weekend breakfast place! - Michelle

+ I called Bagelicious to cater the food for a lunch meeting at the company I work for. Kyle was very attentive to what we needed and made the ordering process very easy. Everything was excellent! I heard many compliments on how delicious everything was. The array of sandwiches was arranged to give everyone a chance to sample several different flavor combinations. The trays were both beautiful and delicious! And the homemade cookies - awesome! They brought all of the little extras to make lunch an enjoyable experience. I would definitely recommend Bagelicious! - Jennifer

+ This is the place to go for a delicious bagel! I miss my Bruegers no longer thanks to this place! Clean, friendly staff, and a nice larger menu. Try the spat's sauce on your bagel sandwich, you will LOVE it. Pairs delightfully with the bagel. - Amanda

+ Great Food, Great Price, If your looking to wake up and go downtown for some breakfast this is in my opinion the best option downtown college ave, you really cant beat locally owned!!! - Colton